ع
Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial in the trial of Lindsay Clancy after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict following more than 38 hours of deliberations over seven days. The panel of nine women and three men had signaled on multiple occasions that it was hopelessly deadlocked with an apparent 11-1 split in favor of finding Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity. WBUR News reported that a final note from the foreperson stated it was with a heavy heart that jurors were unable to come to a decision.
A note sent to the judge indicated that one juror was refusing to follow instructions regarding proof beyond a reasonable doubt even while expressing doubts about Clancy’s responsibility. The New Yorker detailed how defense attorney Kevin Reddington sought removal of that juror and filed an emergency appeal to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court after the judge prepared to end the case. Court records show the appeal was denied within hours leading to the formal mistrial declaration that afternoon.
Clancy a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse has never disputed that she caused the deaths of her children Cora aged five Dawson aged three and Callan aged eight months on January 24 2023. According to testimony compiled by The New York Times she waited for her husband Patrick to leave on an errand before taking the children to the basement of their Duxbury home and strangling each one with exercise bands. She then injured herself with a knife and jumped from a second-story window in a suicide attempt that resulted in paralysis from the waist down.
The five-week trial featured conflicting expert testimony on Clancy’s mental state at the time with more than 80 witnesses called overall. Vanity Fair noted that a prosecution forensic psychologist testified Clancy was not experiencing acute psychosis but instead acted so her children would not suffer after her planned suicide. A defense psychiatrist countered that she was clearly psychotic telling the court it was almost like she was a puppet and someone else was pulling the strings.
The proceedings drew intense national attention and prompted broad discussion of maternal mental health issues in the wake of childbirth. The Times of India reported that hundreds of women gathered outside the courthouse in support of Clancy wearing pink shirts with messages including She Needed Help. Clancy had sought treatment for severe anxiety insomnia and what she described as brain fog after her youngest child’s birth while being prescribed multiple psychiatric medications.
Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz said his office would weigh the possibility of a retrial while stressing the case centered on three murdered children. WBUR News quoted him emphasizing that children were murdered and it is our job to seek justice. Reddington asserted outside court that the jury had been robbed by one holdout juror for whatever his agenda was and suggested prosecutors lacked a viable case.
Clancy remains at a state psychiatric hospital where she has been held since the incident more than three years ago. A status hearing is set for September 29 to address next steps including whether lesser charges or a plea agreement might be pursued in any retrial. The New York Times reported that the mistrial does not resolve the underlying charges against her.
